6.9/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 6.9/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Love Parade remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
You should probably watch this if you have a soft spot for movies that feel like they were filmed inside a giant tin can. It’s 1929, so the sound is a bit crunchy, but the energy is weirdly modern.
If you hate people winking at the camera or singing about their feelings while wearing tiny hats, you should definitely stay away. It’s very much a product of its time, but in a way that feels like a party you weren't invited to but are happy to watch through the window.
Maurice Chevalier plays Count Alfred, who is basically a professional flirt. He’s in Paris getting into trouble with every woman he sees, which is exactly what you expect from a movie like this.
The Queen of Sylvania, played by Jeanette MacDonald, calls him back home to punish him for his scandals. But then she sees him and decides to marry him instead. Talk about a weird HR policy.
It’s a strange power dynamic for a movie this old. She is the boss, and he is just the husband. In 1929, this was probably considered a horror movie for some men.
There is a scene where he has to stand behind her while she does official Queen business. You can see his soul leaving his body. He’s basically a trophy husband before that was even a common phrase.
The songs aren't exactly bangers you’ll be humming in the shower tomorrow. They are more like... rhythmic conversations with some piano in the background. Sometimes they just stop talking and start half-singing, and it’s a bit jarring.
But Jeanette MacDonald has this incredible way of looking at him. Like she wants to kiss him and put him in a cage at the same time. Her facial expressions do a lot of the heavy lifting when the script gets a bit thin.
I noticed that the servants get their own little romance sub-plot. Honestly, it’s almost more fun than the main one. It has that slapstick energy you see in stuff like Peter's Pants.
Lupino Lane is the valet, and he does these little physical comedy bits that feel like they belong in a silent film. Which makes sense, because they basically were still making silent films a year before this. He's got these bendy legs that make every walk look like a dance.
It reminds me a bit of the theatricality in Thais, but way more playful and less... well, less serious. The movie knows it's being silly.
There’s this one part where Chevalier is talking to his dog. The dog looks genuinely confused about why this man is singing to him. I felt for that dog. I really did.
The movie is a bit long for what it is. Around the hour mark, I found myself checking how much time was left on the progress bar. The middle section drags because they keep having the same argument about who is in charge.
Still, Lubitsch has this way of making everything feel naughty without actually showing anything. They call it the "Lubitsch Touch," and you can see it in how he uses doors. A door closes, and you know exactly what’s happening behind it without a single word.
It's not as polished as something like Rip Van Winkle in terms of pure storytelling. But for an early talkie, it’s surprisingly brave. Most movies back then were just people standing still near a hidden microphone.
It deals with the fact that men hate feeling useless. Even if "useless" means living in a palace and being married to a gorgeous Queen. Alfred is so grumpy about it. He just wants to go back to being a scoundrel in Paris.
The ending feels a little rushed, like they realized they needed to wrap it up before the film reel ran out. Or maybe they just ran out of songs. It just sort of... happens.
But honestly? It’s charming. If you can get past the hissing sound of the old audio, there is a real heart here. It’s a movie about a guy who just wants to wear the pants. Literally. There's a whole bit about his uniform.
I'd say give it a watch on a rainy Sunday. Just don't expect it to change your life. It's just a nice, slightly dusty piece of history with some great hats.

IMDb —
1917
Community
Log in to comment.