5.7/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 5.7/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Saturday Night Kid remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you have any love for Clara Bow, you should probably watch this today. It is not some high-art masterpiece, but it’s got that raw, early-sound energy that is just fascinating to sit through.
People who want a fast-paced modern rom-com will probably hate this. It’s slow and the microphones were clearly hidden in flower pots because nobody moves their head too much.
But for anyone who likes seeing how movies used to work, it’s a goldmine. It feels like a real play that someone just happened to film in a basement.
The story is simple: two sisters, Mayme and Janie, work at Ginsberg’s Dept Store. Mayme (Clara Bow) is the good one, and Janie (Jean Arthur) is, well, a bit of a snake. 🐍
They both want the same guy, Bill. Bill is played by James Hall, who is fine, but he mostly just stands there looking confused while these two powerhouses act circles around him.
I forgot how mean Jean Arthur could be in her early roles. We usually think of her as the squeaky-voiced hero, but here she is just awful to her sister.
There is this one scene in their shared bedroom where Janie is just laying into Mayme. The room is so small and cluttered, it feels like a real New York apartment from a hundred years ago.
You can see the dirty clothes and the weird little trinkets on the dresser. It’s those small details that make these old movies feel alive to me. 👗
Clara Bow is just... magnetic. Even when the audio is scratchy and the lighting is a bit flat, you can’t look away from her.
She has this way of looking hurt that feels totally real. When Janie starts lying to Bill to get him away from Mayme, you actually want to yell at the screen.
It’s a lot like Evangeline in how it bridges that gap between the silent era and the talkies. You can tell they are still figuring out how to let actors move and talk at the same time.
One weird thing—Jean Harlow is in this! She plays a girl named Hazel. It is her first credited role, and she’s just... there.
She doesn’t have the Platinum Blonde look yet. She’s just a regular girl in the background, but you can still spot her if you’re looking for those eyes. 👀
The movie gets way better when it’s inside the department store. I love the shots of the old counters and the way the girls have to interact with the customers.
It feels very grounded. Like, these people actually have jobs and they actually need the money.
There is a subplot about a stolen gambling fund that feels a bit forced. It’s like the writers thought a simple love triangle wasn't enough drama for 1929.
The pacing is definitely chunky. Some scenes go on for five minutes of just talking about nothing, and then a major plot point happens in ten seconds.
But that’s part of the charm. It’s not polished. It’s a bit of a mess, actually.
I noticed one reaction shot of Clara Bow that lingers for way too long. She’s just staring off into space while someone else is talking, and it feels like the editor forgot to cut away.
Or maybe they just liked her face that much. I don’t blame them.
It’s definitely more interesting than something like The Savage. It has more personality in its pinky finger than some of the bigger budget stuff from that year.
I kept thinking about how hard it must have been to record the audio. You can hear the hiss of the equipment in the background of the quiet scenes.
It makes the movie feel like a ghost story sometimes. Like you’re eavesdropping on people who have been gone for a century. 👻
The ending is a bit of a rush. Everything gets resolved because someone finally decides to tell the truth, which... okay, sure.
I would have liked to see Mayme give Janie a real piece of her mind. But 1920s sisters had to be a bit more polite, I guess.
If you’re looking for a deep "meditation" on life, look elsewhere. This is a Saturday night movie, just like the title says.
It’s about girls, guys, and trying to keep your job when your sister is a liar. It’s great. 🍿
Anyway, watch it for Clara. She’s the whole reason this thing stays afloat.
It’s better than Youth for Sale by a long shot. At least here, the characters feel like people you might actually meet at a lunch counter.
Just don't expect a masterpiece. It's just a vibe.

IMDb —
1917
Community
Log in to comment.