6.3/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 6.3/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Sultan's Jester remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Is this worth watching today? Only if you are a total nerd for film history or you have a strange obsession with 1930s hats. If you want a movie with a 'plot' or 'logic,' you should probably stay far away from this one. 🤡
It’s basically a talent show held at sword-point. That is the whole movie.
The Sultan, played by Edward Lankow, looks like he stayed up all night and is now being forced to watch a school play. He is very, very grumpy.
He tells the jester to make him laugh or he’s going to get executed. It’s a very simple stakes, but it feels weirdly heavy for a short that is mostly dancing.
Roger Davis plays the jester and you can actually see him sweating. I don't think it's just 'acting' sweat; it looks like those studio lights were about a hundred degrees.
The first thing that hit me was the sound. Since this is from 1930, everything sounds like it was recorded inside a metal trash can. 🗑️
Every time someone moves their feet, it sounds like a small landslide. It makes the dancing feel much more aggressive than it probably was in person.
Then we get the Randall Adagio Four. I have never seen people move like this before.
They do these slow-motion tosses and spins that look like they might snap a bone. One of the guys swings a woman around like he’s trying to start a lawnmower.
The camera just sits there and stares at them. It doesn't move an inch, which makes the whole thing feel like you're spying on a private rehearsal.
I noticed a guard in the background whose helmet was slightly crooked. I spent about three minutes just waiting for it to fall off, but the guy stayed perfectly still.
The sets are... well, they are painted cardboard. You can see the edges of the floor where the 'palace' ends and the dusty studio begins.
It reminds me of the stagey feel in The Dance of Life, but without the budget. Or the charm.
Joyzelle Joyner comes out and does a dance that is supposed to be exotic. She has a lot of energy, but the Sultan still looks like he's thinking about his grocery list.
There is a weird rhythm to the dialogue. The writers, Sid Silvers and Herman Ruby, didn't exactly write Shakespeare here.
It’s mostly just 'Do something funny!' and 'Please don't kill me!' Which, I guess, was the peak of comedy back then.
I kept thinking about Henpecked while watching this. That movie at least felt like it had a joke or two that landed.
Here, the 'jokes' are mostly just the jester looking terrified. Which becomes kind of funny after the fifth time, but then it just gets awkward.
One reaction shot of the Sultan lingers for way too long. He just blinks at the camera for five seconds of pure silence.
I think the editor might have fallen asleep for a second there. Or maybe they just didn't have enough footage to cut away.
The bells on the jester's hat don't even make noise. They probably stuffed them with cotton so they wouldn't ruin the grammary of the audio recording.
It’s those little details that make these old shorts so fascinating. They were clearly just figuring out how to make 'talkies' work.
It feels a bit like The Flower Girl in how it just presents an act and then leaves. There is no 'ending' really.
The Sultan just decides he’s entertained enough and the movie stops. It’s very abrupt.
If you like seeing the seams of how movies are made, you might like this. It’s messy and the acting is way too loud.
But it’s only ten minutes long. You can survive ten minutes of anything, even a grumpy Sultan. 👳♂️
I wouldn't call it a 'classic.' It's more like a weird postcard from a time when movies were still loud and confused.
The Randall Adagio Four are the only reason to stay tuned. I’m still not sure how that girl didn't get dizzy and fall over.
Anyway, it’s better than Woos Whoopee, I guess. But that is a very low bar to clear.
Final thought: The Sultan’s beard is definitely fake. It moves independently of his chin when he talks. 🎅

IMDb —
1927
Community
Log in to comment.