While taking a morning workout, young prizefighter Danny Martin encounters Charlotte Hamilton in distress over her balky roadster. Martin wins his fight but is counted a loser by a crooked referee.

Is 'Her Father Said No' a hidden gem from the past, or a relic best left untouched by modern sensibilities? Short answer: for those with a fondness for early cinematic comedies and...
Archivist John


Comparing the cinematic DNA and archive impact of two defining moments in cult history.

Jack McKeown

Richard Smith
Community
Log in to comment.
In the bustling dawn of a new day, young prizefighter Danny Martin, amidst his rigorous training, chances upon Charlotte Hamilton, a woman of refined upbringing, struggling with her recalcitrant automobile. This serendipitous encounter sparks an immediate connection, but their burgeoning romance is quickly threatened by the stark realities of their disparate worlds. Though Danny triumphs in the boxing ring, his victory is tainted by a corrupt referee, marking him a loser in the eyes of the sport. Later, at Charlotte’s family barbecue, the revelation of Danny’s profession incites the ire of her father, John Hamilton, a man with an unyielding disdain for fighters, leading to Danny’s swift dismissal. Driven by his affection for Charlotte, Danny forsakes his pugilistic career, pivoting to establish a health resort catering to affluent individuals. Irony, however, intervenes when Mr. Hamilton and his preferred suitor for Charlotte, Penrod, arrive at Danny's establishment seeking treatment, their indignation at the resort's methods providing ample comedic fodder. The ultimate revelation of Danny and Charlotte's clandestine elopement, initially sparking Hamilton's fury, eventually softens his stance, forcing a reluctant, yet resigned, acceptance of their happiness.
H.C. Witwer, Al Boasberg
United States


Deep dive into the cult classic
Discover similar cinematic experiences
A Directorial Spotlight on Jack McKeown