Summary
In a mist-laden backwater where the soil itself seems to conspire against hope, Chet Wells—armed with nothing but a cracked agronomy journal and a consumptive mother—plants his shaky future in ground mortgaged by the spider-thin Deacon Todd, a man whose soul is kept in a tin box beneath the floorboards. While buzzards stitch slow circles overhead, Chet’s furrows fail; cash crops wither into burlesque skeletons, and the rent falls due like a headsman’s axe. Enter Emily Burke, betrothed to silk-lined mediocrity yet magnetized to Chet’s feral earnestness; her mercy visits to the dying matriarch become furtive glances, then the hush of gloved hands brushing in lamplight. On the night Todd arrives with the sheriff, words detonate, the sick woman collapses, and Chet’s world gutters out in a single heartbeat. He departs with vendetta soldered to his ribs, leaving the deacon to occupy the hovel like a hermit crab in a cracked shell. Months later, when Major Burke’s temper ricochets off Todd’s greed, a shotgun blast splits the dusk; the deacon vanishes, and the swamp drinks the echo. Chet’s return, gaunt and half-feral, coincides with turkey vultures spiraling over reed and muck—an omen inked against the sky. In a fevered midnight soliloquy the major confesses to empty bottles; Chet, eavesdropping, absorbs the guilt as though it were penance for every seed that ever failed him. Arrest, jailbreak, and a lovers’ elopement careen toward a curtain that yanks itself inside-out, revealing not tragedy but a pratfall—an anarchic wink that upends every grim expectation and sends the audience howling into the aisles.
Synopsis
With his invalid mother, Chet Wells rents a piece of property from Deacon Todd for the purpose of demonstrating Chet's ideas of "scientific farming." Major Burke and his daughter Emily are near neighbors. Emily is engaged to marry a wealthy young neighbor man. Her neighborly kindness to poorly Mrs. Wells brings her into frequent association with Chet, and the young people become fond of each other without openly expressing their mutual regard. Chet is unable to make the farm pay, and when Deacon Todd demands his rent, the young man cannot pay. During the argument Mrs. Wells arises from her bed and the excited conversation between Todd, the sheriff, and Chet gives her such a shock that she falls to the floor, fatally stricken. Chet swears vengeance upon Deacon Todd whom he blames for hastening his mother's death. Finally compelled to vacate, Chet sells his chattel and goes away to seek his fortune. Deacon Todd moves into the house Chet has vacated and an enmity develops between Major Burke and the miserly old deacon, climaxing when the major sends a charge of shot in Todd's direction because he discovers the deacon letting his cows into the major's corn. Todd disappears the night that Chet returns. Suspicion is directed toward Chet because threats he had made to "get even" with the deacon. Major Burke is conscience-stricken when he sees a flock of buzzards hovering over a nearby swamp and fancies that the dead body of his "victim" is the attraction for the vultures. Taking assiduously to drinking for the purpose of quieting his conscience the major is overcome by the stuff and sleeps. Chet enters the major's house to call upon Emily and hears the major talking in his maudlin slumber, revealing the facts in the shooting of Todd. By the same method of transmission, Emily has learned from her own father's lips that truth of "the deacon's demise." When officers come to Burke's house and accuse Chet of the crime the young man admits that he is guilty and tells the officers to search the swamp for Todd's remains. Chet's heroism in submitting himself as a victim to her own father's action greatly stirs Emily's latent admiration, and forgetful of her obligation to marry another, the girl easily surrenders her heart to Chet and proceeds to help him out of his dilemma. Chet is locked in the rickety neighborhood jail and Emily releases him, giving him opportunity to decamp and begging him to take her along to be married. Thus matters arrive at the conclusion of the film, but the exact manner in which the story ends is not revealed. Suffice it to say that the "surprise finish" changes the whole nature of the story from tense melodrama to boisterous farce, ending in the "biggest laugh" ever produced by a moving picture.
Review Excerpt
"
I still remember the first time I saw the buzzards. Not onscreen—on my grandmother’s farm, circling so low their wing-tips tore holes in the sky. That memory slammed back the instant Lynn Reynolds’s The Secret of the Swamp unspooled its opening shot: a carrion bird suspended like a comma between heaven and muck, punctuation for a story that refuses to behave like any 1916 melodrama you’ve met.
Muck, Money, and the Myth of Scientific Farming
Chet Wells (Val Paul) arrives clutching a pamphlet ..."
