DbcultAccessing Vault...
Cult Review
Archivist John
Senior Editor
Short answer: No, but it's a delightful diversion for those with a fondness for vintage slapstick and the sheer absurdity of human behavior.
A Salty Sap is a 1928 short comedy that finds its charm in the physical comedy and the over-the-top performances of its cast. Billy, a naturally dim-witted character, arrives at the reading of his wealthy uncle's will, which stipulates that the million-dollar inheritance will go to the 'dumbest' relative. As the in-laws vie to prove their worthlessness, the film becomes a chaotic and hilarious spectacle of exaggerated behavior and slapstick comedy. While it may not be a masterpiece, it offers a fun glimpse into the early days of cinema and the enduring appeal of physical humor.
This film works because: The physical comedy is raw and engaging. The performances by the cast are exaggerated and over-the-top, which fits perfectly with the film's vintage style. The absurdity of the in-laws' behavior is both hilarious and relatable, as it taps into our shared human tendency to act foolishly in pursuit of gain.
This film fails because: The pacing can be uneven, with some scenes feeling rushed or drawn out. The plot, while simple, lacks the depth or complexity that could elevate it into a true classic. The film relies heavily on visual gags and doesn't delve into the characters' motivations or emotions.
You should watch it if: You're a fan of early 20th-century cinema, physical comedy, or simply enjoy a good laugh at the expense of others' foolishness.
A. Acting: The cast, including Billy Engle and Kalla Pasha, deliver exaggerated and over-the-top performances that fit the film's style perfectly. Their physical comedy and facial expressions are a delight to watch. However, the lack of nuance in their characters' development can make their actions feel more comical than relatable.
B. Directing: The film is directed by Sig Herzig, who clearly understands the style of early comedy. The sequences are well-choreographed, and the timing of the gags is impeccable. However, the direction occasionally feels dated, with some scenes looking a bit stiff or overly controlled.
C. Cinematography: The cinematography is relatively simple, with a focus on capturing the physical comedy. The use of close-ups and medium shots allows for the exaggerated expressions and movements of the cast to shine through. However, the lack of complex camera work limits the visual storytelling potential.
D. Pacing: The pacing can be inconsistent. Some scenes feel rushed, while others are drawn out, making the film feel uneven. The pacing is better during the physical comedy sequences, but it can drag during more dialogue-heavy scenes.
E. Tone: The film maintains a consistent tone of physical comedy and absurdity throughout. The tone is light and humorous, with no attempt to delve into darker or more serious themes. This makes the film more of a pure comedy experience, rather than a character-driven story.
A. Comparison to Other Films: A Salty Sap shares similarities with other films of the era, such as Our Gang and The Avalanche (1919). Both films feature physical comedy and exaggerated performances, but A Salty Sap takes the concept to an even more absurd level. The in-laws' behavior is so over-the-top that it verges on the ridiculous, making for a unique and entertaining viewing experience.
B. Influence: While A Salty Sap isn't directly influenced by any specific film, it is part of a larger tradition of physical comedy in early cinema. The film's reliance on exaggerated physical gags and over-the-top performances can be seen as a precursor to later slapstick comedies, such as Sacrifice and Mark It Paid.
Is this film worth watching? It works. But it's flawed. A Salty Sap offers a fun and entertaining glimpse into the world of early 20th-century comedy, but its reliance on physical gags and lack of character depth limit its appeal. If you're a fan of vintage slapstick and the absurdity of human behavior, it's definitely worth a watch. However, if you're looking for a more complex or nuanced comedy experience, you might want to explore other films of the era.
Verdict: A Salty Sap is a fun and entertaining film for those with a fondness for vintage slapstick and physical comedy. While it may not be a cinematic masterpiece, it offers a unique and humorous take on the absurdity of human behavior. If you're willing to embrace the film's over-the-top style and enjoy a good laugh at the expense of others' foolishness, it's definitely worth a watch. However, if you're looking for a more complex or nuanced comedy experience, you might want to explore other films of the era or more modern comedies.
IMDb —
1916
Community
Log in to comment.
