DbcultAccessing Vault...
6.7/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 6.7/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Commencement Day remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
The inimitable Hal Roach, a luminary of the silent era, crafts a cinematic concoction that defies expectations and revels in unbridled anarchy. Commencement Day (1927) is a sidesplitting romp that careens wildly out of control, much like its lovable, yet hapless, cast of characters.
On the final day of school, a ragtag group of students, led by Lloyd Campbell Jr., Joe Cobb, Lyle Tayo, and Clarke Robinson, embark on a series of misadventures that rapidly spiral into utter chaos. Their bumbling escapades are expertly captured by the deft direction of Hal Roach and the witty script of H.M. Walker.
The film masterfully juggles an impressive array of comedic set pieces, each one more sidesplitting than the last. From pratfalls to mishaps, and from mayhem to pandemonium, Commencement Day is a laugh-out-loud masterpiece that showcases the raw energy and unbridled creativity of its cast.
The cast, a veritable who's who of silent era luminaries, delivers performances that are at once nuanced and over-the-top. Lloyd Campbell Jr., Joe Cobb, and Lyle Tayo form a comedic triumvirate that is simply irresistible, their on-screen chemistry igniting a spark that sets the film ablaze.
One cannot help but draw comparisons to other Hal Roach productions, such as The Arizona Cat Claw (1927) and Not Guilty (1927), both of which share a similar brand of humor and anarchy. However, Commencement Day stands apart, its unique blend of slapstick and witty banter setting it apart from its contemporaries.
The film's pacing is expertly handled, with a narrative that flows like a well-oiled machine. Each scene seamlessly blends into the next, creating a sense of continuity that is all too often lacking in modern comedies. The cinematography, while not overly complex, adds to the overall sense of mayhem, capturing the chaos and anarchy that ensues.
In an era dominated by Seein' Things (1927) and Wonders of the Sea (1927), Commencement Day stands as a beacon of creativity and innovation. Its influence can be seen in later films, such as Racing Hearts (1928) and Keith of the Border (1929), both of which owe a debt to Roach's pioneering work in the comedy genre.
Upon reflection, it becomes clear that Commencement Day is more than simply a comedic romp; it's a masterclass in filmmaking. The film's use of The Crimson Gardenia (1927)-esque dramatic irony and Girl of the Sea (1927)-inspired pathos adds depth and nuance to an otherwise chaotic narrative.
The technical aspects of the film are equally impressive, with a Mortmain (1927)-like attention to detail and a Polly Ann (1927)-esque sense of scope. The editing is seamless, with a Sauce for the Goose (1927)-like sense of rhythm and flow.
Lest one forget, Commencement Day is, above all, a comedy. Its humor, while rooted in the silent era, remains timeless, a testament to the enduring power of Ipnosi (1927)-style physical comedy and Outcast (1922)-esque wit.
In conclusion, Commencement Day is a landmark film that showcases the very best of Hal Roach's brand of humor. With its talented cast, expert direction, and innovative storytelling, it's a must-see for fans of silent cinema and comedy.
If you're a fan of Love and Hate (1927) or Through the Dark (1927), then Commencement Day is sure to be a hit. So sit back, relax, and enjoy the anarchic romp that is Commencement Day (1927).
IMDb 6.4
1915
Community
Log in to comment.
