Recommendations
Senior Film Conservator

For those who were mesmerized by Is Conan Doyle Right?, a true Short masterpiece from 1923, the quest for comparable cinema becomes a journey through the fringes of film history. Our curated selection of recommendations echoes the very essence of Is Conan Doyle Right?.
The legacy of Is Conan Doyle Right? is built upon its ability to create a hauntingly beautiful cinematic landscape.
Documentary exposé of the then-popular fad of spiritualism, of which Arthur Conan Doyle was a proponent.
Based on the unique artistic bravery of Is Conan Doyle Right?, our vault has identified these titles as the most compelling follow-up experiences for fans of Short cinema:
Dir: Mason N. Litson
Edgar and his chum try to amass a fortune in one day by cornering the fan market on a hot afternoon when the circus comes to the small town where they are spending their vacation.
View Details
Dir: Unknown Director
A fascinating piece of cinema that shares thematic elements.
Dir: Jack Harvey
During World War I, an illegitimate son of the German Kaiser, who had been raised in the US--and is a double for the the Kaiser's son, the Crown Prince--is sent to Germany as a spy in order to kill both the Kaiser and his son.
View Details
Dir: William F. Adler
A travelogue/documentary including explorations of the fauna and people of Siam, New Guinea, and Java, with interpolations of an apparently fictitious encounter between the filmmakers and cannibalistic natives of Frederick Henry Island in the South Pacific.
Dir: Reggie Morris
A fascinating piece of cinema that shares thematic elements.
View Details
Dir: Unknown Director
The Judge needs a present for his wife's birthday, so Harry suggests a new corset. They go to the shop, but he's so embarrassed to ask the saleslady he hides in a phone booth.Harry goes in, but finds a GUY wearing one, and runs out.They both dress as women to get back in, but Mrs. Rummy gets there and chases him out.
Dir: Richard Smith
Two female candidates for Chief of Police live across the hall from each other, and their political rivalry follows them home, leading to plenty of hi-jinks.
View Details
Dir: Unknown Director
The village youths are rivals for the hand of the local belle. Their battles lead them to the village store, where chaos soon reigns, terminating in the place being blown up, leaving Bobby a happy victor.
Dir: Jack Harvey
Colonel Roger Craighill, a Pittsburgh millionaire, is seen presiding at a meeting in the directors' room of the Hercules Bank. He tells them that he intends to crush Gregory, an independent coal operator. He decides to use his accomplice, Walsh, for this purpose. In the next scene we see Gregory and his granddaughter, Jean. Gregory's mines have remained idle as the syndicate has refused him transportation to tidewater, and he has been rendered poor as the result of this oppression. Jean, who is an artist, earns a little money by the sale of her pictures for the upkeep of her family. Craighill's son, Wayne, while attending a football game, sees that Joe Denny, the son of an old miner of his home town, has been injured and goes to his assistance. He meets Adelaide Churchill and her mother. Wayne is very much taken with Adelaide, but when he sees her in a loving attitude with a student of his college at the last football game he decides to forget her. After his graduation, Craghill places Wayne in charge of Walsh, who takes him to the town where Gregory's plant is located. There he meets Jean. Gregory asks Wayne to use his influence with the Pittsburgh syndicate to have his coal mine put in operation. When he learns that he has been talking to the son of the man who had ruined him he is about to attack Wayne when Jean intercedes. We next see Jean in her cottage brooding over her grandfather's losses. She decides to take more active measures to assist him, and goes to the city to sell some of her pictures at an art store, where she happens to meet Wayne, who had gone to the city to plead with his father to cease throttling his competitors. He is unsuccessful, however. Wayne gives Joe Denny a job as his chauffeur. The scene shifts to the college town where Craighill is addressing a Chautauqua audience on the evils of the working classes. After the lecture, Addie and her mother are introduced to Craighill and he appears very much impressed with Addie. In the city Joe recognizes Jean while he is waiting in his capacity of chauffeur, before the Craighill office for Wayne to come out. Wayne invites Jean to enter the car, and Jean motors them to her home. Joe shows his suspicion as he observes Wayne's attitude toward Jean. Meanwhile, after a rapid courtship, Craighill and Adelaide are married. Brooks, a tool of Walsh, incites the men at the mills to strike and desert the furnaces at midnight, while Craighill is out of town. Wayne hears of the strike and rushes to the mills. He is successful in getting the men to return to the mills. Craighill returns from his honeymoon, and introduces Addie to Wayne as his wife, not aware that they had ever met. Subsequently we see Wayne making love to Jean, but Jean tells him that there is a gulf between them she fears can never be bridged. When Wayne reaches home, he stops to engage in conversation with Addie in front of the house and they overhear a bitter argument that is going on between Craighill and Gregory. Suddenly there is a sound of a fall. Rushing up to the library, they find Gregory with Craighill bending over him. Wayne stoops to examine the prostrate form upon the floor just as Joe enters. Wayne announces that Gregory is dead. Joe goes to Jean's house and tells her of her grandfather's death. Wayne goes to Jean's house for the same purpose and Jean tells him for the first time of her marriage to Joe. In the next scene we see the United States bank examiner at the Hercules Bank, where he discovers an overdraft of $100,000 together with other notes that have not been met. The bank is compelled to close its doors as Craighill cannot meet the required payments. Just as Jean and Joe are returning from the funeral of Gregory, news reaches the mining town that Craighill's bank has failed. A mob storms the Craighill home and tries to batter down its doors. Craighill pleads with the mob without avail. Then Wayne goes out and tells the people that just as he settled the steel strike, he now pledges his word that he will pay dollar for dollar owned by the wrecked institution. It is now pay day at the steel mills, but no money has arrived. At the bank in the city, crowds are swarming, trying to get into the institutions which have closed. In the mining towns we see the miners start to blow up the mines while Joe watches the men plant the fuse. Wayne starts from the city to try and pacify the workmen at the mills. When he gets there he finds that mine after mine has been destroyed. Joe has been seriously hurt and Wayne, seeing this, goes into one of the mines to get him. When Wayne comes out, the explosions have shaken the earth and from the interior oil has begun to spout. In the place of the wrecked coal mine we see geyser after geyser of shooting oil and natural gas, which greatly increases the value of Craighill's property. Meanwhile the banks which have been appealed to for assistance have refused financial aid, as Craighill's assets were not ample security. The discovery of oil and natural gas changes matters completely and the banks now decide to come to the relief of Wayne and his father. We see Jean mourning for the death of Joe and then as she leans her head on Wayne's shoulder, it is evident they have plighted their troth.
View DetailsAnalysis relative to Is Conan Doyle Right?
| Film Title | Atmosphere | Complexity | Similarity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Get-Rich-Quick Edgar | Tense | Abstract | 95% Match |
| Trail of the Rails | Tense | Layered | 96% Match |
| Kaiser's Finish | Surreal | High | 96% Match |
| Shipwrecked Among Cannibals | Surreal | Linear | 86% Match |
| Striking Models | Tense | High | 96% Match |
This guide was algorithmically generated using the cinematic metadata of Jack Harvey's archive. Last updated: 8/16/2026.
Back to Is Conan Doyle Right? Details →