A Jewish patriarch would prefer that his attractive daughter have one of their kind as a boyfriend, but she easily succumbs to an "Irisher" suitor who literally stalks her through the streets..


Is Why Girls Say No a hidden gem of the silent era? Short answer: Yes, but only if you have the stomach for the aggressive 'persistent suitor' tropes that defined 1920s romantic comedies. This film is for enthusiasts of the Hal Roach 'factory' style and those who appreciate the specific, neurotic brilliance of Max Davi...

product


Comparing the cinematic DNA and archive impact of two defining moments in cult history.

Leo McCarey

Unknown Director
Community
Log in to comment.
"Is Why Girls Say No a hidden gem of the silent era? Short answer: Yes, but only if you have the stomach for the aggressive 'persistent suitor' tropes that defined 1920s romantic comedies. This film is for enthusiasts of the Hal Roach 'factory' style and those who appreciate the specific, neurotic brilliance of Max Davidson; it is not for modern viewers who find the concept of a romantic 'stalker' more disturbing than humorous. Direct Answer: The Critical Verdict 1) This film works because Max D..."
H.M. Walker, Hal Roach, Stan Laurel
United States

